Islamorada Key or Marathon Key: Which is better for a vacation?

Sharing is caring!

Are you looking for the perfect spot to vacation in the Florida Keys? 

If so, you may be wondering if Islamorada Key or Marathon Key is the better choice. 

Both islands offer amazing scenery and plenty of things to do, but they are definitely different. 

So, which one is right for you? 

Read on to find out!

Islamorada Key or Marathon Key

Who has the best beaches? 🏖

Islamorada Key

Islamorada Key beaches

If you’re looking for some of the best beaches in Islamorada Key, you won’t be disappointed. Its crystal clear waters and soft white sand, make Islamorada Key a beachgoer’s paradise. 

Whether you’re looking to relax on the beach or take part in some of the many activities available, there’s something for everyone. 

Popular activities include swimming, fishing, snorkeling, and kayaking. 

There are also several restaurants and bars located nearby, making it easy to grab a bite or drink in between swims. 

So if you’re looking for a perfect place to enjoy the sun and sand, be sure to check out the beaches of Islamorada Key.

Marathon Key

Sombrero Beach
Sombrero Beach

The beaches of Marathon Key are renowned for their soft white sand and turquoise blue waters. But there’s more to the beaches on Marathon Key than just their good looks.

The Florida Keys are home to some of the best fishing in the world, and Marathon Key is no exception. Marathon Key attracts anglers from around the country to try their luck at catching sailfish, marlin, tuna, and other big game fish. 

And if fishing isn’t your thing, then you can enjoy the other attractions that the Marathon Key has to offer, including amazing restaurants, bars, shops, and watersports.

Whether you’re looking for a place to relax or a place to get your adrenaline fixed, Marathon Key has a beach that’s perfect for you.

If you’re looking for a beach that’s great for swimming and offers serenity, then Sombrero Beach is an underrated gem. The water is crystal clear, and the sand is white and powdery. There’s also a range of amenities on offer, including showers, restrooms, and picnic tables. 

If you’re after a more secluded spot, then Boot Key Harbor is worth a visit. It’s a beautiful sheltered cove with turquoise waters and a sandy bottom that are a treat to the eyes. 

And if you’re hoping to catch a glimpse of some marine life, then head to the historic Seven Mile Bridge. This stretch of water is home to a variety of fish, turtles, and stingrays which you can see either by foot, bike or by taking a ferry ride along the bridge.

Whichever beach you choose, you’re guaranteed to have an enjoyable time in Marathon Key.

👉 Must-read: Is Marathon Key Worth Visiting? Pros and Cons to Help You Decide!

🏖 Related post: Key West vs Siesta Key for a Vacation? An Honest and In-Depth Comparison!

Who has the best nightlife? 🍻

Islamorada Key

Islamorada Key is best known for its tropical vibe and laid-back atmosphere. 

However, that doesn’t mean that there isn’t anything to do at night. 

In fact, there are plenty of bars and clubs to keep visitors entertained well into the wee hours. 

One of the most popular nighttime hangouts is Morada Bay Beach Café, which offers live music and dancing against the backdrop of a stunning ocean view. 

For those looking for a more intimate setting, Rum Bar Key West is the perfect spot for sipping on handcrafted cocktails. 

And for those who want to keep the party going until sunrise, Tortuga Rum Co. hosts a nightly happy hour with DJ-spun tunes. 

No matter what your taste, you’re sure to find a nightlife hotspot that suits you in Islamorada Key.

Marathon Key

And there’s no better time to experience its unique magic than at night.

Marathon Key, although known for its peaceful Florida charm offers plenty of things to do at night, from watching the stars on one of the many beaches to dancing the night away at one of the many clubs and bars. 

But my personal favorite is taking a walk along the pier. There’s something about the rhythmic sound of waves crashing against the wooden planks that always seems to soothe my soul. 

And of course, there’s also the magnificent view of the stars twinkling overhead. It’s an experience that I never get tired of and one that I would recommend to anyone visiting Marathon Key.

If laid-back nights are not your thing then there’s no shortage of bars and clubs to choose from, and the party doesn’t stop until the sun comes up.

Whether you’re looking to dance the night away or simply relax with a drink in hand, you’ll find plenty of options to suit your needs. 

And if you get hungry, there are plenty of late-night dining options to keep you going until morning. So if you’re looking for a place to let loose and have some fun, Marathon Key is the perfect destination.

🏖 Related post: Siesta Key vs Lido Key for Vacation? An Honest & In-Depth Comparison

Activities & Best Things to do 🏄🏼‍♂️

Islamorada Key

Couples enjoying kayaking through the mangrove tunnels

Islamorada in the Florida Keys is a great place to relax and enjoy the outdoors.

There are many things to do in Islamorada, from fishing and swimming to kayaking and hiking. 

The best time to visit Islamorada is between December and April when the weather is warm and sunny. 

Fishing is also a popular activity in Islamorada, and there are many charter companies that offer half-day and full-day trips.

Snorkeling and diving are other popular activities, and there are many reefs and shipwrecks to explore.

There are also many festivals and events held throughout the year, such as the Annual Stone Crab & Seafood Festival, which celebrates the area’s richness in seafood. 

Whether you’re looking for a relaxing vacation or an exciting adventure, Islamorada is sure to have something for you.

Marathon Key

Turtle Hospital

Marathon Key is a beautiful place with plenty to do. 

The most obvious things to do in Marathon Key are the lovely pristine beaches here, and there are several to choose from. 

You can go swimming, sunbathing, fishing, or just exploring the coastline. 

Marathon Key is also home to several amazing nature parks that are worth visiting. 

If you are an outdoor enthusiast and a nature lover then the Crane Point Hammock is a great place to explore the local wildlife, and it’s also a beautiful spot for a picnic. 

The Dolphin Research Center is another highlight on the Marathon Key – it’s a non-profit organization dedicated to rescuing and rehabilitating injured dolphins. The Research Center offers great interactive tours where you can learn about these intelligent creatures and you can even swim with them if you want! 

Have you heard about a hospital for turtles? In Marathon Key, you can visit one. The Turtle Hospital is the only non-profit organization in the world dedicated solely to the purpose of rehabilitating endangered sea turtle species. 

The hospital offers educational tours where you can get up close and personal with these gentle giants.

Do you love the lively nightlife? If yes, then there are plenty of bars and restaurants to keep you busy.

Overall, Marathon Key is a great place to visit and there’s something for everyone to enjoy at night.

Conclusion 👍

Marathon Key is better for a vacation if you are looking for more nightlife and activities. Islamorada Key is great if you are looking for a quieter, more relaxed getaway.

Both islands offer beautiful beaches and plenty of places to stay and eat.

Islamorada Key has the advantage of being closer to Miami, while Marathon Key is closer to Fort Lauderdale.

There is no clear answer as to which of the Florida Keys is better for a vacation. Islamorada and Marathon Key are both beautiful places with plenty to offer visitors.

Islamorada may be a bit quieter and laid back than Marathon Key, while Marathon Key offers more nightlife options.

Both islands have great beaches, fishing, diving, and kayaking opportunities.

In the end, it really comes down to personal preference as to which island is best for you.

Photo of author
About the author
James Williams
Hey there! I'm James Williams, the guy behind I'm a born-and-raised Floridian, and I'm stoked to share my travel adventures with you. On my website, you'll get a taste of Florida through my eyes – the places I love, the hidden gems, and the stories that make the Sunshine State special. Join me on this journey as I take you through the heart and soul of Florida, one post at a time!

Leave a Comment